By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Gary Sheffield Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (3,527)
2020's (152)
2010's (105)
2000's (1,950)
1990's (1,177)
1980's (143)
Listings 1 - 100 of 3,527
2001 SP Authentic - [Base] #61

Gary Sheffield [JSA Certified COA Sticker]

$273.34
2022 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #90T-718

Gary Sheffield (1990 Topps) [Buyback] #/1

$317.01
2021 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #04TT-TT18

Gary Sheffield (2004 Topps Total Topps) [Buyback] #/1

$209.10
1999 Upper Deck MVP - [Base] - Super Script #109

Gary Sheffield #/25

$176.10
2025 Topps Series 1 - 1990 Topps Baseball Autographs - Black #90A-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/10

$175.00
1995 Topps Stadium Club - Clearcut #13

Gary Sheffield [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$175.00
2024 Topps Pristine - Pristine Pieces Autograph Relics - Gold Refractor #PPAR-GS

Gary Sheffield [SGC 10 GEM] #/50

$165.10
2002 Donruss Classics - New Millennium Classics #NMC-55

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/500

2 from
$9.17
2022 Leaf Lumber - Bat Rack 3 Relics - Emerald #BR3-23

Gary Sheffield, Albert Belle, Greg Vaughn [CGC 9.5 Mint+] #/4

$152.99
1991 Topps - [Base] - Factory Set Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #68

Gary Sheffield [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$142.00
1990 Topps - [Base] - Box Set Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #718

Gary Sheffield [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$142.00
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Golden Anniversary Refractor Missing Serial Number #68

Gary Sheffield

$121.10
2005 eTopps - [Base] - Anaheim #53

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/1

$115.24
2004 Leaf Certified Cuts - [Base] - Marble Gold Position Materials Signatures #208

Gary Sheffield #/10

$64.02
2004 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Silver Framed Signatures #82

Gary Sheffield #/5

$63.63
2013 Topps Supreme - Retired and Active Autographs - Black #SA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/5

$63.63
1989 Upper Deck - [Base] #13.2

Gary Sheffield (Right Side Up SS on Front) [BAS BGS Authentic]

$114.22
1999 Topps Finest - [Base] - Gold Refractor #99

Gary Sheffield #/100

$88.47
1992 Upper Deck - [Base] #84

Bloodlines - Gary Sheffield, Dwight Gooden [BAS BGS Authentic]

$103.75
2001 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Signatures - Silver #GS

Gary Sheffield #/24

$41.83
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* Next to PERFORMANCE) [BAS Authen…

$101.21
1989 Bowman - [Base] - Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #142

Gary Sheffield [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$64.19
1993 Classic Best Gold Minor League - Autographs #_GASH

Gary Sheffield [BAS BGS Authentic] #/2,050

$94.73
1997 Fleer Ultra - [Base] - Platinum Medallion Edition #P202

Gary Sheffield

$92.53
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - Fabric of the Game - AL/NL Autographs #FG-164

Gary Sheffield #/10

$87.71
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - Fabric of the Game - Autographs #FG-164

Gary Sheffield #/10

$87.71
2006 Bowman Originals - Buyback Autographs #3.2

Gary Sheffield (2003 Bowman Chrome) [Buyback] #/6

$51.37
2017 Topps Triple Threads - Unity Autograph Jumbo Relics - Silver #UAJR-GH

Gary Sheffield #/75

$37.23
2021 Topps Rip - [Base] #50

Gary Sheffield #/99

2 from
$21.47
2005 Topps Pristine - [Base] - Uncirculated #146

Base Uncommon - Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/100

$10.03
2020 Topps Museum Collection - Signature Swatch Dual Relics - Copper #SSDA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

$86.79
1996 Select Certified Edition - [Base] - Blue #3

Gary Sheffield #/180

2 from
$46.24
2004 Donruss Throwback Threads - Player Threads - Triple Memorabilia #PT-24

Gary Sheffield #/250

$9.17
2004 Donruss Leather & Lumber - Lumber & Leather - Bat/Ball #LUL-16

Gary Sheffield #/25

2 from
$9.17
2003 Upper Deck Authentics - Star Quality Game-Used - Gold #SQ-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2004 Fleer Sweet Sigs - Sweet Stitches - Jersey Red #ST-GS

Gary Sheffield #/125

$9.17
2004 Donruss Studio - Players Collection Relics - Platinum #PC-29

Gary Sheffield #/50

$9.17
2004 Donruss Studio - Masterstrokes - Bats/Jerseys #MS-5

Gary Sheffield #/50

$9.17
2005 Donruss Timeless Treasures - Rookie Year Materials - Year #RYM-21

Gary Sheffield #/100

$9.17
2005 Donruss Studio - Heritage - Combo Materials #SH-8

Gary Sheffield #/50

$9.17
2003 Topps Tribute - Contemporary Edition - Perennial All-Stars - Red #PA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

$9.17
2008 Upper Deck Spectrum - Retrospectrum Swatches - Red #RS-GS2

Gary Sheffield #/45

$9.17
2004 Donruss Throwback Threads - Century Collection Material - Prime #CC-29

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2001 Donruss Studio - Warning Track #WT-3

Gary Sheffield

2 from
$9.17
2005 Upper Deck Trilogy - Generations Present - Gold Materials #PR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2005 Playoff Prestige - Diamond Heritage - Jerseys #DH-11

Gary Sheffield [Good to VG‑EX] #/100

$9.17
2002 Leaf Certified - Fabric of the Game - Silver Die-Cut Jersey Number #FG 88

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/10

$9.17
2005 Playoff Prime Cuts - [Base] - Bats #48

Gary Sheffield #/50

$9.17
2003 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Jersey - Tier 2 #J-GS2

Gary Sheffield #/75

$9.17
2003 Bowman Heritage - Diamond Cuts - Red #DC-GS

Gary Sheffield #/56

$9.17
2004 Leaf - Players Collection Jerseys - Green #PC-28

Gary Sheffield

$9.17
2004 Leaf - Players Collection Jerseys - Platinum #PC-28

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2004 Topps Clubhouse Collection - [Base] - Black #GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2004 Topps Clubhouse Collection - [Base] - Copper #GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

2 from
$9.17
2004 Fleer Sweet Sigs - Sweet Stitches - Jersey Silver #ST-GS

Gary Sheffield #/88

$9.17
2008 Upper Deck Baseball Heroes - [Base] - Charcoal Memorabilia #63

Gary Sheffield

$9.17
2008 Topps - All Rookie Team 50th Anniversary Relics #ARR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

$9.17
2004 Donruss Timeless Treasures - Rookie Year Materials #RY-15

Gary Sheffield #/89

2 from
$9.17
2004 Donruss Elite - Career Best - Jerseys Prime #CB-15

Gary Sheffield #/50

$9.17
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Blue Mirror Bat #67

Gary Sheffield #/100

$9.17
2005 Playoff Prestige - League Leaders Single - Bats #LLS-1

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/250

$9.17
2018 Panini Chronicles - Classic Singles - Holo Gold #CLS-GS

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/15

$9.17
2018 Panini Chronicles - Classic Singles - Gold #CLS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/49

$9.17
2018 Panini Chronicles - Classic Singles - Blue #CLS-GS

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/25

$9.17
2005 Playoff Prime Cuts - [Base] - Position Jersey #48

Gary Sheffield #/50

2 from
$9.17
2018 Panini Diamond Kings - Bat Kings - Holo Silver #BK-GS

Gary Sheffield #/49

$9.17
2005 Upper Deck Trilogy - Generations Present - Lumber #PR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/115

3 from
$9.17
2004 Fleer Sweet Sigs - Sweet Stitches - Patch Gold #ST-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

$9.17
2017 Panini Chronicles - Swatches #CS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/49

$9.17
2005 Topps - All-Star Patch Relics #ASP-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2002 Fleer Maximum - Coverage #_GASH

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/100

$9.17
2004 Leaf - Players Collection Jerseys - Platinum #PC-29

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2005 Donruss Elite - Back 2 Back Jacks - Combos #BBJ-10

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/100

$9.17
2016 Panini National Treasures - Leagues Best #LL-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$9.17
2016 Panini National Treasures - [Base] #135

Gary Sheffield #/49

2 from
$9.17
2016 Panini Pantheon - [Base] - Guilds Gold #21

500 Home Runs - Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/49

$9.17
2016 Panini Pantheon - Arena Acclaimed - Gold #AA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

2 from
$9.17
2016 Panini Pantheon - Arena Acclaimed #AA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/49

$9.17
2001 Pacific - Game-Worn Jerseys - Patch #3

Gary Sheffield #/226

$9.17
2002 Upper Deck Authentics - Retro UD Star Rookies Jerseys - Gold #SR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/275

$9.17
2004 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Sweet Sticks #SSS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/199

$9.17
2013 Topps - Chasing History Relic - Gold #CHR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$9.17
2002 Upper Deck Diamond Connection - [Base] #503

History Makers Bats - Gary Sheffield #/150

$9.17
2003 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Mirror Red Materials #14

Gary Sheffield #/250

$9.17
2005 Upper Deck First Pitch - Fabric #GU-GS

Gary Sheffield

$9.17
2005 Upper Deck All-Star Classics - Midsummer Patches #MSP-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2004 Leaf Limited - [Base] - TNT Combo Materials #166

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2003 Donruss Timeless Treasures - Rookie Year Materials #RY-19

Gary Sheffield #/100

$9.17
2003 SPx - Winning Materials - Red 175 Team Logo #WM-GS2

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/155

$9.17
2005 Topps Turkey Red - Relics - Red #TRR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

3 from
$9.17
2003 SPx - Winning Materials - 375 Team Logo #WM-GS1

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/335

$9.17
2002 Leaf Certified - [Base] - Mirror Red Materials #117

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/150

$9.17
2004 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Threads Jersey Number #166

Gary Sheffield #/25

2 from
$9.17
2003 Upper Deck - Piece of the Action #PA-GS

Gary Sheffield

$9.17
2005 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Majestic Materials - Gold #MM-GS

Gary Sheffield #/75

$9.17
2005 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Majestic Materials - Platinum #MM-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$9.17
2005 Donruss Classics - Home Run Heroes - Combo Materials #HR-11

Gary Sheffield #/36

$9.17
2005 Playoff Prestige - League Leaders Single - Jerseys #LLS-1

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/250

$9.17
2005 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Mirror Gold Materials Bats #45

Gary Sheffield #/25

$9.17
2005 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Mirror Blue Materials Bats #45

Gary Sheffield #/100

$9.17
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 36